ArLyne's Diamonds

A running commentary of ideas

Thursday, June 04, 2020

Onvestigating a Complaint in the Workplace


Topic Title:  Investigating a Complaint in the Workplace

Background:  Years ago, when children complained of being sexually abused, they were disbelieved and ignored.  When, in the eighties professionals realized that many of these allegations were true.  Trying to protect children they coined the phrase:  “Children Don’t Lie, Or if they do, they don’t lie about this.”  Thus all complaints were accepted as true even if the allegation was that the abuse had happened more than ten years prior to the complaint. 

Fast forward to now.  Thanks to some of the people involved in the #Metoo Movement we are now demanding that if a woman (and sometimes a man) complains of having been sexually abused they are automatically believed.  It is considered bad form and intrusive to question the complaining person. 

When doing evaluations of these allegations in the business world, we are told, over and over again that the complaining woman (and sometimes a man) is promised confidentiality and the alleged perpetrator has no right to face his accused.  Investigations if they are conducted at all  - are all too often conducted by a biased person who is looking only for evidence to support the complaint and the potential evidence to the contrary is ignored – or else that person is called a liar. 

Having “second opinioned” many of these poorly conducted investigations, I wrote the book:  Conducting Workplace Investigations: Designed Investigator. 

Labels: , ,

Saturday, May 12, 2018

Should harassment be treated the same as abuse?

I abhor sexual abuse - or abuse of any kind for that matter.  I am delighted that #MeToo has brought out so many people (mostly women - but some men) to tell about what happened to them YEARS AGO and some recently.

BUT to ruin lives about some stupid remark, or awkward requests for dates doesn't seem fair at all.

I find it particularly obnoxious that now that we are in an election cycle so many people (mostly men) runnint for office are being accused publicly of alleged behavior that happened so many years ago.

Rape - violence - abuse - should be prosecuted without a statute of limits.  Harassment - meaning annoying, irritating and often stupid behavior should have a statute of limitations.  Either you report it formerly within six months or it can't be made public..... That's the only fair way to apply due process to what would be  an infraction or misdemeanor at most.

YES, let's stop harassment, abuse, rape forever.   But how far back are you willing to go to ruin someone's reputation, profession and possibly life because of some stupid inappropriate behavior that happened more than 10 years ago. 

Should we be treating these stupid harassing behaviors the same as violence, abuse, rape?

Labels: , , , ,

Tuesday, April 24, 2018

#MeToo could become #YouToo

It is shocking to learn how many companies are still avoiding offering training in proper workplace behavior (alias:  Preventing Harassment , Discrimination and Bullying in the Workplace.)

Others, onl;y thinking about the cheapest and easiest are providing the basic on-line training complimenting themselves on being in compliance.

Sure, you may be in compliance, but the research has shown that poor to mediocre training doesn't make any change.  If you want to really change attitudes and behavior you must provide opportunities for discussion, Q&A and role-playing.  This can only be accomplished with face-to-face training.

My clients report having far greater understanding  of why behavior that they thought was OK was actually found to be offensive by others.

So - do you want a lawsuit?  Do you want to have to fire someone who misbehaved?  What bout you losing your job and reputation - it has happened to prominent CEOS.....

Labels: , , , ,

Tuesday, March 06, 2018

I didn't do it


I didn’t do it!

What do you do if you have been falsely accused of harassing someone in the workplace?  That’s a question I’ve been asked a great deal lately.  Hopefully, this will never happen to you, but if it does…

  • ·       Remember that you have the legal right to due process.  That means to face your accuser, to learn the charges against you and to receive enough information to be able to defend yourself.  That includes, who, what, when, why and where.
  • ·       Unfortunately, all too often the people doing the investigations in the workplace think that they are protecting the accuser (alleged victim) by not giving the alleged harasser/abuser the name or details of the allegation.  I think this is wrong.
  • ·       If the accusation rises to the level of criminal behavior – such as grabbing, physically abusing or raping another person – get thee to an attorney fast.
  • ·       If the accusation is of the milder annoying and insulting kind – demand an open and neutral investigation.  That is assuming you are innocent.
  • ·       Most investigations, trying to be neutral wind up being biased in favor of one side or the other.  That’s because we all have natural biases.  (see my book:  Conducting Workplace Investigations:  Designated Investigator, Robertson Publishing Com.)  Investigators need to learn their own biases and how to get out of the way of them.
  • ·       If you are innocent, the openness of the investigation will lend credence to your claims of innocence.  Otherwise, once accused you will have a very hard time being believed when you say I am innocent.
  • ·       If you are not receiving a neutral – open – and unbiased investigation, you might consider going up your organization chain of command to find someone who will help guarantee that your investigation is as it should be.

Most claims are probably true.  But in today’s climate, it stands to reason that there will be women (and some men) wo falsely accuse because they want publicity, money or both.  There are some attorneys who are determined to make fame and fortune out of bringing so-called victims forward.
  • ·       We need to carefully separate out credible claims, ones that have facts and proof that make them logical and believable from those that can’t be proven.
  • ·       If a claim is a he said/she said about something that happened years ago, it might be exceedingly difficult to prove or disprove.  (That is probably why, in the Bill Cosby case the prosecution is trying to have a number of alleged victims testify.)
  • ·       Yes, the #metoo movement is creating a powerfully positive message – no more will women, girls and some men and boys allow themselves to be victimized.  They will shout NO and come forward to complain – and we will listen.  Me must honor the positive aspects of the movement.

·       But, it does also lend itself to bringing out the people who just want to get something for nothing – both in the workplace and elsewhere.
This is a tightrope we are currently walking – between believing the alleged victim and giving the alleged perpetrator due process.

Labels: , , ,