ArLyne's Diamonds

A running commentary of ideas

Wednesday, June 08, 2016

Building Trust in Distant Teams


In the past we developed teams by putting people together and letting them spend time learning about each other before we charged them with completing assignments. In spite of all our best efforts, some teams were more successful than others.  

In order to be honest and forthcoming with others, a level of trust must exist. The less we trust, the more guarded and self-protective we become. That’s one of many reasons it’s a challenge to work effectively in teams. The challenge increases tremendously when the people involved haven’t been given the opportunity to get to know each other personally.

Today’s workplace consists of people working on projects who have never met each other face to face. Indeed many of them live in other countries. Those that might live close to their corporate headquarters often work from their homes, “telecommuting” and are rarely available for face to face meetings.

Trust is not easy to develop in the best of circumstances – when working with distant teams the problems increase tremendously. In addition, the team is frequently being led by a Project Manager – who has a dotted line relationship to the others and thus very little authoritative leverage. The Project Manager can only manage through persuasion and negotiation – two methods requiring a high level of trust.

Professor Larry Leifer at Stanford University discovered that when he had students working in teams from different locations members complained that they were doing more work than other teammates. When camcorders were placed in their cubicles so that they could see each other at work, the complaints diminished considerably. Apparently, the very act of seeing someone situated at their keyboard increased the belief that they were working hard.

We know that visual clues are critically important. In addition to Dr. Leifer’s research, there is a vast body of psychological research that has to do with how people perceive others based entirely on looks.

The more contact we have with another human being (assuming that they are basically trustworthy) the easier it is to trust them. One could even hypothesize that at some unconscious level, our sense of smell plays a part in what has to be seen as primarily an emotionally (psychologically) based decision.
  
Sound – or voice quality – is less effective than visual clues. When we know someone only due to our telephone interaction with them, we develop less personal or positive feelings than when we actually sit across the table from them.

We also have the variable of “low-context” and “high-context” cultures. Low context cultures are those in which business is conducted without developing personal relationships. This is akin to our decision to buy something from a discount or big box store. High context cultures are those in which relationships are developed long before the business discussions commence. You might relate this to your decision to work with a consultant, or a decorator, or even shopping regularly in a small private boutique store.

Most Asian cultures and France are considered “high-context” cultures. The development of relationship precedes the desire to do business, or even to doing a good job. This adds another dimension to the problems of building trust between people here in the states and their counter-parts in Asia or other parts of the world.

Given these problems, here are some tips to developing trust in distant teams:
  • Allow members of the team to take the time to get to know each other on a somewhat personal level.
  • Have in-house discussions, at all locations, about what is proper to ask and discuss and what crosses the line into intrusive or inappropriate.
  • Share pictures – not only of the staff, but also of their families. Most people are family oriented and grow to like (and trust) each other when they start to see pictures of their children and to hear stories about them.
  • Send your managers to the locations of their team members whenever possible. Although this is an expense, the potential value in developing trust, respect, and therefore greater levels of understanding and productivity is immeasurable.
  • Teach cultural diversity. Let the people in the various locations around the world learn as much as possible about the behaviors, customs, and expectations of those in other areas with whom they work.
  • If you have telecommuters who can be brought into the office once or twice a month, be sure to have as many face to face meetings as possible with them.
  • Use video-conferences and video-cams where feasible.
In other words, break some of the old rules that demand full focus on work related conversations only. Getting to know each other adds to the ability to work together well. 

Take the time and create the structure that enables people to develop relationships that lead to trust – which leads to cooperation, understanding, and higher productivity and creativity.

Labels: , ,

Saturday, November 21, 2015

There is a ME in Teams


What follows is an excerpt of a talk I recently gave to an HR Group.

Personally, I cringe every time I hear the expression “there is no I in teams.”  It suggests that all the strategic planning, idea generation, implementation and troubleshooting are done by some vaguely anonymous group of people.

I think about a firing squad.  It takes a dozen people to kill one person because that way no one can be held responsible.

I think about bizarre interview teams who are all in the room at the same time asking pre-designed questions (to be fair!) so that no one can be blamed if the wrong person is hired.

I think about communism under Mao – where everyone had to wear the same colorless jumpsuits so that no one would stand out.

I think about Ayn Rand’s book “Anthem” the futuristic story of people who had no names, but were given numbers instead – no individuality.

Ok – now that I’ve vented….

I want to ask you some questions:  I suggest my reader actually takes a moment to answer these questions for yourself – and if you have someone near you – ask them as well.

·       When you were a child and your mother forced you to share a favorite toy or game, what was your feeling?
·       When in High School how did you feel if someone you knew “stole” your boyfriend or girlfriend?
·       How did you feel when as part of a small study-group team you wound up doing much of the work, but had to share the credit with some of your more lazy classmates?
·       Ladies – what’s your reaction when you attend a very dressy function and discover someone else wearing the same dress or gown as you?
·       If you were the creator of a new app that became famous – how would you feel if you didn’t get the patent or royalties?

Switch gears with me – think about sports and sports teams.  Each player has an important role and when the team scores, the person or persons who made the play is given credit on the news.  Yes, they all work together in harmony as a team, and in fact they each in their own way contribute to the success (or failure) of the game.  However, one or two people actually made the touchdown,goal or home – run.

·       How do you think a player would feel if he ran the entire field with the ball and the newscaster talked about someone else having made the goal?

Now, you are going to tell me it is different in the workplace.  In the workplace the emphasis on teams assumes that  everyone is equal – and equally responsible for the work-product.

I’ve seen facilitators interrupt a conversation flow to announce that X spoke for 5 minutes and now it was Ys turn – when in fact the most important information was coming from X.

In our quest to be fair – we tend to step all over the brightest and most talented people.  Instead, we need to respect and nourish each person’s unique talent and unique gift and work together to allow it to shine.  That’s what happens in a winning sports team.

Let me tell you the story of the 20th Century Motor Factory. (adapted from Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged.)

It had the reputation of being the best in the business.  It’s trademark stood for quality – excellence. That was one of many reasons it attracted the best and brightest of engineers and other staff.  Unfortunately, some years after wining many awards for excellence the original founders died and their adult children (products of one our ultra-liberal universities) took over the business and created what they considered to be the best social experiment.

It was to compensate people based on their need – not on their ability.  So, if the janitor had four children he received a higher rate of pay than the engineer who was single.  When someone’s wife became pregnant, instead of rejoining all groaned since it meant less money in their pockets.  The best and the brightest quit.  The company failed.

 Meritocracy works!

How do you create and maintain successful teams?   Again, since this has been adapted from a speech – I asked my audience to make suggestions.  These are mine, which I contributed after receiving theirs.
  • The most important element is the leader/facilitator and their ability to see level.  It takes level to see level (Kung Fu – black belts)
  •  The leader of the group  controls how people interact and show respect for each other. (there really is no such thing as a leaderless group someone always assumes responsibility.)      
  •  Each member of the group needs to learn about each other – both some personal stuff and professional stuff – the object is for each of us to learn to respect the expertise of the other.  In other words – Walk in his shoes.
  • Team needs to have a shared vision/mission and goals.
  •  Each member needs to be held accountable for his/her role in meeting those goals.
  • Being “fair” is not as important as being true.
  • Being nice – “don’t say anything unless you have something nice to say” can destroy the effectiveness of an organization.  People need to be able to “constructively criticize.”
  • People in the team – whether a board of directors, an executive team, or a work-team all need to learn how to make decisions that are based on some logical structure – not on favoritism and being loyal to your friend or boss.
  •   Rewards and recognitions need to be carefully handled – not just given out to everyone willy-nilly.
So – let’s eliminate the phrase:  there is no I in team and instead change it to:

Working together we achieve far more than we could achieve alone.

Labels: , ,